The FL125 Greatest Captain voting shortlists were compiled from data submitted by Football League clubs, which was collected from fans through social media. Supporters were asked to submit their suggestions by interacting with their respective clubs through Twitter, using  and .

The nominees were:

Barry Kitchener - Legendary longest serving Millwall player who led by example and wore his heart on his sleeve.

Keith Stevens - Followed very much in Kitch's footsteps, a born winner and leader.

Les Briley - Skippered a side full of big characters, Stevens, Hurlock, Sheringham and Cascarino to the Second Division title in 1988 and top flight football.

Paul Robinson - The current club captain, one club man, perfect gentleman off the field and scorer of the winner in the 2010 Play-Off Final.

The FL125 Greatest Manager voting shortlists were compiled from data submitted by Football League clubs, which was collected from fans through social media. Supporters were asked to submit their suggestions by interacting with their respective clubs through Twitter, using and .

The nominees were: 

Kenny Jackett - Guided Millwall to consecutive Wembley League 1 Play-Off Finals, winning promotion in 2010. Established club in Championship and led Millwall to FA Cup semi-final in 2013.

Benny Fenton - Longest serving post-war manager. Under him, Millwall completed record breaking 59-game unbeaten run of home games. Narrowly missed promotion to First Division (top flight) in 1971/72.

John Docherty - Took Millwall from the lower reaches of the Second Division (Championship) to the top flight for the first time in the club's history, winning the Division Two title in the process. Twice Millwall topped the League during a two-year stay in the First Division.